For slush makers, go Ninja 3‑in‑1 for compact batches; choose Ninja 5‑in‑1 for capacity and presets; pick the All‑In‑One for the lowest tier.
Ninja 3‑in‑1 (FS300)
Ninja 5‑in‑1 (FS301)
UJR All‑In‑One
Lowest Cost Route
- 6 presets with temp readout.
- Auto‑clean + dishwasher‑safe parts.
- Great for treats plus soft‑serve.
UJR All‑In‑One
Balanced & Party‑Ready
- Five presets for slush, frappé, milkshake, juice, spiked.
- 88‑oz vessel; 7+ servings per batch.
- Built‑in rinse cycle for quick resets.
Ninja 5‑in‑1 (FS301)
Small‑Batch Ninja Route
- Three presets for everyday drinks.
- Narrower body; easy counter fit.
- Lowest Ninja price tier.
Ninja 3‑in‑1 (FS300)
Home slush machines turn your favorite drinks into icy treats without blender noise or melting ice. Ninja’s two versions focus on drink programs and batch size, while the All‑In‑One model adds soft‑serve to the mix. This guide gives you the quick verdict first, then the trade‑offs that steer everyday buyers.
In A Nutshell
The 3‑program Ninja fits smaller batches and tighter counters. The 5‑program Ninja brings party‑size capacity, five presets, and a rinse cycle for faster back‑to‑back rounds. The All‑In‑One aims at budget‑minded buyers who like the idea of slush plus soft‑serve from one appliance. Pick based on batch size, presets, and whether you want ice cream in the mix.
Side‑By‑Side Specs
The big gaps: presets, batch size, and whether you want a rinse cycle or a temp screen. Those three items drive daily ease.
Ninja 3‑in‑1 (FS300) — What We Like / What We Don’t Like
✅ What We Like
- No‑ice operation with RapidChill auger for even freezing.
- Three one‑touch programs keep choices simple.
- Narrow body fits spots where wider machines don’t.
⚠️ What We Don’t Like
- Fewer presets; no dedicated frappé or frozen‑juice mode.
- No built‑in rinse cycle, so back‑to‑back rounds take longer.
Ninja 5‑in‑1 (FS301) — What We Like / What We Don’t Like
✅ What We Like
- Five presets including frappé and frozen‑juice.
- Large 88‑oz vessel yields 7+ servings in one round.
- Built‑in rinse cycle speeds changeovers between flavors.
⚠️ What We Don’t Like
- Taller and heavier, so it claims more counter space.
- Highest tier on total cost among the three.
UJR All‑In‑One — What We Like / What We Don’t Like
✅ What We Like
- Six presets plus a soft‑serve mode in one unit.
- Auto‑clean and a real‑time temperature readout.
- Lower cost tier for a wide feature set.
⚠️ What We Don’t Like
- Capacity isn’t listed as clearly as the others.
- Brand track record and parts access aren’t as established as Ninja’s.
ℹ️ Good To Know: All three rely on sugar content to freeze properly. If you use low‑ or no‑sugar liquids, add a suitable substitute. Let new units sit upright for two hours after delivery so the refrigerant settles before first use.
Ninja 3‑in‑1 Or 5‑in‑1 Or All‑In‑One: Which Fits You Better
Power & Throughput
Both Ninja models use a self‑cooling cylinder with an auger that scrapes and stirs while chilling. That design freezes evenly and avoids big ice chunks. The three‑program version is tuned for everyday drinks and smaller groups. The five‑program version scales up with an 88‑oz vessel and presets for frappé and frozen‑juice style mixes. The All‑In‑One’s pitch is breadth: slush plus a soft‑serve mode, backed by a temp display you can watch as it cools.
Noise & Comfort
Any self‑cooling slush machine hums while the compressor runs. The auger adds a steady whir when it turns. The three‑program Ninja tends to feel less imposing because of its slimmer footprint and the way it tucks under cabinets. The five‑program Ninja is taller; it still fits on most counters but wants a bit more headroom for loading and cleaning. The All‑In‑One sits wide to fit the screen and controls, which some buyers prefer for visibility.
Cleaning & Parts
Rinse‑and‑reset speed matters if you’re making multiple flavors. The five‑program Ninja includes a rinse cycle right on the panel, plus dishwasher‑safe parts for the main pieces (FS301 product page). The three‑program Ninja skips the rinse button but still breaks down for the dishwasher. The All‑In‑One adds a one‑touch auto‑clean, useful if you plan to switch between slush and soft‑serve modes in a single afternoon.
Safety & Standards
Give each unit stable counter space, keep vents clear, and run with the lid locked. All three designs rely on sugar content to slush; straight water or unsweetened drinks won’t freeze as intended. Ninja’s support pages also recommend that you wait two hours after moving the machine before first use, which helps protect the cooling system (FS300 Series FAQs).
Warranty & Service
The five‑program Ninja lists a one‑year limited warranty on the product page and benefits from the brand’s parts network and documentation. The three‑program Ninja is part of the same family, so accessories and care steps are familiar. The All‑In‑One is sold by a merchant brand; warranty and parts availability depend on the listing and seller, which is fine for casual, budget‑minded use where absolute uptime isn’t a priority.
Cleaning & Parts Detail (By Model)
Ninja 3‑in‑1 (FS300): dishwasher‑safe core parts, manual rinse in the sink when changing flavors. Ninja 5‑in‑1 (FS301): built‑in rinse cycle plus dishwasher‑safe parts; handy for back‑to‑back rounds on busy days. All‑In‑One: one‑button auto‑clean helps when swapping between slush and soft‑serve modes. If you expect lots of variety in one sitting, a rinse or auto‑clean button is worth paying for.
How Presets Change Real Life
Presets aren’t just names. They’re pre‑tuned temperature targets and auger timings. A dedicated frappé mode runs colder and longer for dairy‑heavy mixes; a frozen‑juice mode aims for a lighter, spoonable finish. If you often make just slush and milkshakes, the three‑program Ninja has you covered. If your menu rotates between milkshakes, frappés, and juice‑based mixes, those extra two programs on the five‑program model remove guesswork. The All‑In‑One brings six presets and covers both drink and dessert textures in a single body.
Capacity & Time
Batch size sets the pace. A 72‑oz vessel suits families and weeknight treats. An 88‑oz vessel covers parties and bigger cookouts in one pass. Cycle time climbs as you fill the tank. That’s why the brand quotes a broad 15–60 minute window at max load on the smaller unit and points to roughly a half‑hour on the bigger one. A temp display can help you judge readiness even when the maker doesn’t publish an exact minute‑by‑minute timeline.
Ingredients & Results
Slush depends on sugar content. Soda, juice blends, chocolate milk, sweetened coffee, and wine spritzers slush well. Diet sodas and unsweetened drinks need a compatible sugar substitute. If you want café‑style frappés, pick a model with the dedicated program so the cylinder temp and auger timing match dairy‑based mixes. For soft‑serve cravings, the All‑In‑One is the only unit here with a built‑in ice‑cream mode.
Space & Ergonomics
Measure the gap between your counter and wall cabinets. The slimmer Ninja is easier to park near a backsplash, and the handle clears most cabinet lips. The larger Ninja needs more vertical clearance for loading. The All‑In‑One’s screen is easiest to read from across the kitchen; if visibility is a must, that one feels friendliest.
Price, Value & Ownership
If you switch flavors often, a rinse or auto‑clean mode saves time and sink trips. For long events, the bigger Ninja’s 88‑oz vessel cuts re‑fills.
Where Each One Wins
🏆 Capacity — Ninja 5‑in‑1
🏆 Soft‑Serve — UJR All‑In‑One
🏆 Simplicity — Ninja 3‑in‑1
🏆 Back‑to‑Back Rounds — Ninja 5‑in‑1
Decision Guide
✅ Choose Ninja 3‑in‑1 If…
- You want a slimmer machine for limited counter depth.
- Your menu is mostly slush and milkshakes.
- You’re fine rinsing parts in the sink between flavors.
✅ Choose Ninja 5‑in‑1 If…
- You host often and want 7+ servings per batch.
- You like dedicated programs for frappé and frozen‑juice.
- You want a rinse cycle for quick flavor swaps.
✅ Choose UJR All‑In‑One If…
- You want the lowest cost tier with lots of modes.
- You like the idea of slush and soft‑serve from one body.
- You prefer a screen that shows real‑time temperature.
Best Fit For Most Households
Most buyers should start with the five‑program Ninja. It covers the widest drink range in one panel, carries the biggest batch size, and includes a rinse cycle so you can pour again without walking to the sink. If you’re space‑limited or your menu stays simple, the three‑program Ninja does the core job in a slimmer body. If you want slush plus soft‑serve at the lowest cost tier, the All‑In‑One is the playful pick that keeps kids and guests smiling.
Details compiled from official brand pages and product listings, including Ninja’s FS300 Series FAQs and the FS301 product page, plus the UJR All‑In‑One listing.