Ninja DT251 vs DT501: Smart Pick or Heavy Hassle?

If you can’t decide between the Ninja DT251 and DT501, here’s the key thing. The DT251 has a smart thermometer. The DT501 does not. I cooked with both in my Dallas kitchen.

On busy school nights, that one feature made a big difference. Both ovens heat fast. Both cook food evenly. Both fit family meals. But only one keeps roasts from drying out. After weeks of testing, here’s what I learned so you can pick the right one for your home.

Ninja DT251 Review

When I first got the Ninja DT251, I was unsure. Could it really replace my big oven? After weeks of cooking, I can say it’s one of the best countertop ovens I’ve used. It’s fast, versatile, and a huge help on busy nights. I roast chicken, bake cookies, and toast bread before school with ease. This oven has earned a spot in my Dallas kitchen.

The best part for me is the built-in Foodi Smart Thermometer. It takes the guesswork out of meat. I stick the probe in a roast, choose the doneness, and walk away. The oven stops when the food is ready. For a mom with many tasks at once, that’s a game changer.

It also heats up fast—about 90 seconds. No more waiting an hour for the big oven.

What I Like

• Smart Thermometer: My roast beef came out perfect. No stress, no dry meat.
• Fast Preheat: Ready in under two minutes. Great for quick meals when kids are hungry.
• Large Capacity: It fit a 12-pound turkey at Thanksgiving. Impressive for a counter oven.
• Even Cooking: Cookies baked evenly on two racks. No burnt bottoms.
• Handle Display: Lights show rack spots so I never guess.

What Could Be Better

• Cleaning: Hard to reach the back wall and fan. Grease builds up.
• Noise: The fan is loud on Air Fry. Not bad, but you notice.
• Size: Big and heavy. Could feel bulky on small US counters.
• Air Fry Results: Fresh wings are great, but frozen fries are less crispy.

Ninja DT251 Quick Overview

Recommendation

If you want a countertop oven that can replace your big oven, get the Ninja DT251. It’s great for:

• Families: Cooks plenty of food, even a holiday turkey.
• Busy parents: Fast heat and smart probe make life easier.
• Home cooks: Perfect doneness every time.

It’s not perfect. Cleaning is tough, and it’s heavy. But the pros beat the cons. If you’re torn between the Ninja DT251 vs DT501, pick the DT251. You get the smart probe included, and that’s what makes this oven truly “smart.”

Ninja DT501 Review

When I tried the Ninja DT501, I wanted to see if it could match my DT251. At first, they look the same—big, sleek, and made for family meals. But after weeks of use in my Dallas kitchen, I noticed some clear changes. The DT501 is fast and strong but does not have the smart thermometer. That feature made the DT251 stand out.

I used the DT501 for many weeknight meals. It baked chicken thighs with veggies and came out even every time. It preheats in about 90 seconds, which saves time. It fits two 12-inch pizzas at once. For snacks, it toasted bread and bagels well, without burning. This is a good pick if you want a big oven but don’t need the probe.

What I Like

• Fast Preheat: Heats up in about 90 seconds. Great for busy nights.
• Large Capacity: Two frozen pizzas fit with no crowding.
• Even Baking: Cookies turned golden on both racks. No tray switching.
• Versatile Modes: Air fry, roast, toast, bake, and more in one.
• Solid Build: Feels sturdy and well-made, not cheap.

What Could Be Better

• No Smart Thermometer: I missed the Foodi Smart Probe. Had to use my own.
• Cleaning: Grease builds up on the back wall like the DT251. Needs extra effort.
• Size: It’s big and heavy. Small U.S. counters may feel cramped.
• Air Frying: Fresh wings were crisp, but frozen fries were softer.

Ninja DT501 Quick Overview

Recommendation

The Ninja DT501 is a strong pick for speed, power, and space. It works well for:

• Families: Handles pizza night or holiday sides.
• Busy parents: Heats in under two minutes. A lifesaver on school nights.
• Home cooks: Great for baking and roasting.

But if you cook meat often, the Ninja DT251 is better. The smart thermometer saves stress and gives perfect doneness.

Both ovens are solid, but if you must choose, I’d lean toward the DT251. That probe feature is worth it.

Ninja DT251 vs DT501 Details Comparison

I cooked with both the Ninja DT251 and DT501 side by side. At first, they look the same. But daily use showed me small details that matter, especially for family meals. Here’s how they compare.

Heating Speed: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both ovens heat fast—about 90 seconds. This is great on busy nights when kids are hungry. No big difference here.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 9/10

Cooking Capacity: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both are roomy. The DT251 roasted a 12-lb turkey. The DT501 handled two pizzas with ease.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 9/10

Cooking Functions: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both have 10 modes. I air fried wings, roasted veggies, and baked cookies. Results were close. Frozen fries were softer.

Rating: DT251 – 8/10 | DT501 – 8/10

Smart Features: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Here is the big change. The DT251 has the Foodi Smart Thermometer. It stops when meat hits doneness. The DT501 has no probe.

Rating: DT251 – 10/10 | DT501 – 7/10

Build & Size: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both are big and heavy. They look premium but need space. Cleaning the back wall is tricky.

Rating: DT251 – 7/10 | DT501 – 7/10

Performance: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both cooked evenly. Cookies were golden on both racks. The DT251 probe gave better roasts.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 8/10

Ease of Use: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

Both have clear screens and quick preheat. The DT251 wins because I didn’t watch the meat.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 8/10

Value for Money: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

The DT501 costs less but lacks the probe. For me, the probe is worth it if you cook meat often.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 8/10

Overall: Ninja DT251 vs DT501

After weeks of cooking, I pick the DT251. The smart probe is the tie-breaker. It saved roasts more than once.

Rating: DT251 – 9/10 | DT501 – 8/10

FAQs on Ninja DT251 vs DT501