There’s nothing quite like a perfectly crafted bourbon cocktail. Whether you’re unwinding after a long day or hosting a gathering, the right mixer can transform a good pour into an unforgettable experience. It’s about balance, depth, and that undeniable touch of sophistication that elevates your drink from simple to sublime.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind KitchPrep. With over 15 years of dedicated experience analyzing extensive market data on cocktail ingredients, scrutinizing flavor profiles from countless culinary reports, and dissecting customer experiences to understand true mixology preferences, I bring a unique perspective to selecting the finest bar essentials.
Finding the ideal companion for your favorite bourbon can be a delightful journey, whether you prefer the classic elegance of an Old Fashioned or the zesty kick of a Whiskey Sour. We’ve meticulously analyzed countless options to bring you a definitive guide, ensuring you discover the best mixers for bourbon that will truly transform your home bar experience.
How To Choose The Best Mixers For Bourbon
Selecting the perfect mixer for your bourbon depends on your desired cocktail, preferred flavor profile, and how much effort you want to put into preparation. Consider these key factors to make an informed choice.
Flavor Profile & Cocktail Type
Are you aiming for a sweet, tart, smoky, or spiced drink? Old Fashioned mixes typically offer a balance of sweetness, bitters, and citrus, while Whiskey Sour mixes lean into tart lemon or lime notes. Bitters add complexity and depth, often with herbal or spicy undertones. Consider if you want a complete mix or individual components to build your own.
Convenience vs. Craft
Ready-to-use liquid mixes offer ultimate convenience, requiring just a pour and a splash of bourbon. Powdered mixes are great for portability and long-term storage. For those who enjoy the ritual of mixology, individual bitters, garnishes, or infusion kits allow for greater customization and a true craft cocktail experience, though they require more time and ingredients.
Quality of Ingredients
Look for mixers made with natural, high-quality ingredients like real fruit juices, pure cane sugar, and authentic bitters. Organic and non-GMO options are available for those who prioritize clean labels. The quality of your mixer directly impacts the final taste, so investing in premium ingredients can make a significant difference.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Type | Best For | Key Feature | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix | Liquid Syrup | Overall Quality | Exceptional Balance | AmazonCheck Price |
| Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix | Liquid Syrup | Easy Crafting | Award-Winning Recipe | AmazonCheck Price |
| Bartender’s Secret Sauce Old Fashioned Mix | Organic Syrup | Organic Enthusiasts | USDA Organic Ingredients | AmazonCheck Price |
| Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch | Accessory Kit | Smoky Flavors | 6 Wood Chip Flavors | AmazonCheck Price |
| Bluestem Botanicals Old Root Gift Set | Gift Set | Botanical Cocktails | Ginger, Bitters, Kumquat | AmazonCheck Price |
| McKinnon’s Dry Craft Cocktails Bourbon Trio | Infusion Kit | DIY Infusions | Dehydrated Fruits & Herbs | AmazonCheck Price |
| Fee Brothers Whiskey Barrel-Aged Bitters | Bitters | Aged Complexity | Vanilla & Oak Notes | AmazonCheck Price |
| Cocktail Crate Mixer Spiced Old Fashioned | Spiced Syrup | Spiced Drinks | Cinnamon & Allspice | AmazonCheck Price |
| The Cocktail Box Co. Old Fashioned Kit | Travel Kit | On-The-Go | Compact & Portable | AmazonCheck Price |
| Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries | Garnish | Premium Garnish | Bourbon-Steeped Cherries | AmazonCheck Price |
| Daniel’s Broiler Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mixer | Liquid Mix | Restaurant Quality Sours | Lemon, Lime & Organic Sugar | AmazonCheck Price |
| Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix | Liquid Mix | Quick Old Fashioned | Cherry, Citrus & Bitters | AmazonCheck Price |
| Master of Mixes Old Fashioned Drink Mix | Liquid Mix | Everyday Value | Dark Cherry & Orange Blend | AmazonCheck Price |
| Fee Brothers Old Fashion Cocktail Bitters | Bitters | Classic Bitters | Savory Zest | AmazonCheck Price |
| Bar-Tenders Instant Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mix | Powdered Mix | Portable Sours | Sweet & Tart Balance | AmazonCheck Price |
In‑Depth Reviews: The Best Mixers For Bourbon
1. Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix
Check Latest PriceThe Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix stands out as a true game-changer for anyone seeking a premium, effortlessly balanced Old Fashioned at home. Crafted with real bitters and cane sugar, this syrup delivers a rich, traditional flavor profile that rivals what you’d find in a high-end cocktail lounge.
Old Fashioned aficionados widely agree that this syrup consistently delivers an exceptional balance of sweetness, depth, and smoothness. Many users have expressed that it has completely transformed their home cocktail game, eliminating the need for separate simple syrups and bitters. It’s lauded for its ability to save time without compromising on quality, making it a favorite for both seasoned mixologists and those new to crafting drinks.
If you’re looking for the gold standard in Old Fashioned mixes and appreciate the convenience of a handcrafted syrup that truly tastes authentic, this is an outstanding choice. It’s perfect for entertaining or simply enjoying a professional-grade drink after a long day, offering consistent, delicious results every time.
Why it’s great
- Exceptional, consistent balance
- Made with real bitters and cane sugar
- Quick and easy preparation
- High-end bar quality at home
Good to know
- Higher price point
- May encourage drinking more Old Fashioneds!
2. Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix
Check Latest PriceThe Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix offers a refined recipe that makes crafting the perfect Old Fashioned incredibly simple. This award-winning syrup (2025 SIP Awards Platinum winner) is designed to deliver a well-balanced, smooth, and layered cocktail with minimal effort, making it a standout addition to any home bar.
Many home bartenders praise this mix for its rich flavor profile, which includes tart organic cherries, fresh orange peel, cinnamon, clove, cardamom, and bitter herbs. They particularly appreciate that it’s a complete mix, requiring only the addition of your favorite whiskey, bourbon, or rye. The ease of use, combined with the exceptional taste, often leads to it being hailed as the best Old Fashioned mix they’ve tried.
This mix is ideal for anyone seeking an easy yet sophisticated way to enjoy a classic Old Fashioned. It’s perfect for those who want a consistently delicious drink without the fuss of muddling or sourcing multiple ingredients. Just pour, stir, and enjoy a cocktail that tastes like it was made by a seasoned pro.
Why it’s great
- Award-winning, balanced flavor
- Handcrafted with organic cherries and orange zest
- Non-GMO and gluten-free
- Yields many cocktails per bottle
Good to know
- Requires refrigeration after opening
- Some find the cap difficult to open initially
3. Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix
Check Latest PriceFor those who prioritize natural and organic ingredients, Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix delivers a delicious and consistently balanced cocktail. This handcrafted syrup simplifies the Old Fashioned, ensuring a smooth, bar-quality drink every time with minimal effort.
Whiskey lovers rave about the unique and flavorful concoction, noting its thick consistency that blends easily and allows for more bourbon per drink. Many find it on par with the best homemade infusions, highlighting the convenience of skipping the drying of fruits and keeping raw sugar on hand. The organic, gluten-free, and non-GMO ingredients are a significant draw for health-conscious sippers.
If you’re seeking an Old Fashioned mix that combines exceptional taste with a commitment to organic, high-quality ingredients, this is an excellent choice. It’s perfect for entertaining, batching cocktails, or simply stocking your bar with a reliable and delicious option that’s both easy to use and health-conscious.
Why it’s great
- USDA Organic, Gluten-Free, Non-GMO
- Yields up to 64 cocktails per bottle
- Thick syrup allows for custom ratios
- Delicious and unique flavor profile
Good to know
- Slightly higher price point
- Some find it a little sweet, but adjustable
4. Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch
Check Latest PriceFor those who love to add a dramatic and flavorful twist to their bourbon, the Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch is an exciting addition to any home bar. This comprehensive kit allows you to infuse your drinks with a tender smoky flavor, elevating classic cocktails to a new sensory experience.
Many users report that this kit is incredibly fun and easy to use, even making cheaper whiskeys taste delicious. The kit comes complete with a premium torch, six different flavors of wood chips, and various accessories like ice cubes and an ice ball mold. Cocktail enthusiastsappreciate the ability to customize their drinks with different wood chip aromas, from oak to apple, enhancing the overall drinking experience.
This kit is perfect for the bourbon enthusiast who enjoys experimentation and adding a unique, smoky dimension to their cocktails. It’s also an excellent gift for men who appreciate craft cocktails and love to impress guests with a sophisticated, visually appealing drink. Just remember to grab some butane for the torch before you start smoking!
Why it’s great
- Comprehensive kit with many accessories
- Six distinct wood chip flavors included
- Easy to use for smoky infusion
- Great for unique gifts and entertaining
Good to know
- Butane for torch not included
- Requires a few minutes for infusion
5. Bluestem Botanicals Old Root (Old Fashioned) Whiskey Mixer Gift Set
Check Latest PriceThe Bluestem Botanicals Old Root Whiskey Mixer Gift Set offers a unique, botanically focused approach to the classic Old Fashioned. This premium non-alcoholic kit includes Ginger Simple Syrup, Aromatic Cocktail Bitters, and a Kumquat Aromatizer, allowing you to craft sophisticated, flavorful drinks.
Cocktail enthusiasts and mocktail creators alike consistently praise this kit for its amazing flavors and ability to produce high-end restaurant quality drinks. The ginger simple syrup, in particular, is highlighted for its pungent and powerful aroma, pairing exceptionally well with various whiskies and bourbons. Reviewers enjoy the creative freedom this set provides, encouraging them to explore new taste combinations.
This gift set is ideal for those who appreciate bold, botanical flavors and a refined Old Fashioned experience. It’s perfect for gifting to cocktail enthusiasts, hosts, or anyone looking to elevate their home bar with unique, organic mixed drink options, whether they choose to add spirits or enjoy a vibrant mocktail.
Why it’s great
- Organic, high-quality botanical ingredients
- Unique ginger, kumquat, and aromatic flavors
- Versatile for cocktails and mocktails
- Thoughtful gift presentation
Good to know
- Aromatizer spray might be inconsistent
- Recipe cards might be limited
6. McKinnon’s Dry Craft Cocktails Bourbon Trio
Check Latest PriceMcKinnon’s Dry Craft Cocktails Bourbon Trio offers a delightful and interactive way to create complex, mouthwatering bourbon infusions at home. This 3-pack set features tightly sealed glass mason jars filled with dehydrated fruits, herbs, and spices, allowing you to infuse your favorite bourbon with unique flavors.
Home mixologists appreciate the fun and ease of making these drinks, noting the delicious results from flavors like Cranberry Sauced, Hot Toddy, and Sangria. The ability to get two infusions from each jar, yielding up to 16 drinks, is a significant value point for many. Users enjoy the fresh, natural goodness of the ingredients and the simplicity of the infusion process.
This infusion kit is a fantastic choice for the DIY mixologist or anyone looking for a creative, hands-on approach to bourbon cocktails. It makes an excellent gift for birthdays, Father’s Day, or Christmas, offering a unique experience that results in delicious, custom-flavored spirits.
Why it’s great
- Three unique flavor infusions in one set
- Uses natural dehydrated fruits and herbs
- Each jar yields up to 16 drinks
- Fun and interactive DIY experience
Good to know
- Requires 3 days for infusion process
- Bourbon not included
7. Fee Brothers Whiskey Barrel-Aged Cocktail Bitters
Check Latest PriceFee Brothers Whiskey Barrel-Aged Cocktail Bitters are a limited edition aromatic product designed to bring unique depth and complexity to your bourbon cocktails. Aged in whiskey barrels, these bitters offer a distinct flavor combination that truly enhances the drinking experience.
Dedicated cocktail makers consistently rank these among the best bitters they’ve ever tried, particularly for Old Fashioneds and Manhattans. The heavy vanilla and oak notes, along with spicy undertones, are frequently highlighted as perfectly complementing bourbon and rye. Many appreciate that these bitters are a key ingredient in creating truly exceptional, layered cocktails.
If you’re serious about your bourbon cocktails and want to introduce a sophisticated, barrel-aged complexity, these bitters are a must-have. They are ideal for mixologists who enjoy experimenting with nuanced flavors and elevating their drinks beyond the ordinary, offering a truly special aromatic dimension.
Why it’s great
- Aged in whiskey barrels for unique flavor
- Adds vanilla, oak, and spicy notes
- Enhances Old Fashioneds and Manhattans
- Limited edition for a special touch
Good to know
- Can be harder to find due to limited edition
- A bit pricier than standard bitters
8. Cocktail Crate Mixer Spiced Old Fashioned
Check Latest PriceThe Cocktail Crate Mixer Spiced Old Fashioned offers a delightful twist on the classic, infusing it with warm, aromatic spices. This gluten-free, allergy-friendly syrup is designed for quick and easy preparation, delivering a delicious Old Fashioned with a distinctive spiced character.
Frequent users of this mixer consistently enjoy its delicious taste and reliability for making Old Fashioned cocktails. Many highlight the strong presence of cinnamon and allspice, which adds a nice spicy note to the traditional profile. Some even suggest adjusting the recommended 1 oz per drink down to 0.75 oz to achieve a less sweet, more balanced flavor, which also yields more drinks per bottle.
This spiced mixer is an excellent choice for those who enjoy a warm, autumnal flavor profile in their bourbon cocktails. It’s perfect for casual sipping or for adding a unique touch to gatherings, especially during cooler months. The ability to adjust sweetness to personal preference makes it versatile for various tastes.
Why it’s great
- Adds distinctive cinnamon and allspice notes
- Gluten-free and allergy-friendly facility
- Quick, easy, and reliable preparation
- Adjustable sweetness to taste
Good to know
- Some find the cinnamon flavor very strong
- Price can fluctuate on different platforms
9. The Cocktail Box Co. Old Fashioned Cocktail Kit
Check Latest PriceThe Cocktail Box Co. Old Fashioned Cocktail Kit is a brilliant solution for crafting quality cocktails anywhere. This compact, travel-friendly kit includes all the essentials needed for a classic Old Fashioned, making mixology accessible whether you’re on a plane, camping, or simply enjoying a quiet evening at home.
Travelers and gift-givers consistently find this kit to be fun, convenient, and cleverly packaged. Many appreciate that it includes everything from bitters and old fashioned cubes to a muddler and stirrers, all neatly organized in a compact tin. It’s frequently cited as a perfect unique gift, especially for those who enjoy taking their cocktail crafting on adventures.
If you’re someone who loves a good Old Fashioned but needs the flexibility to make it on the go, this kit is an absolute must-have. It’s also an ideal gift for whiskey lovers, offering a sophisticated and portable way to enjoy their favorite drink, transforming any setting into a personalized bar experience.
Why it’s great
- Perfectly packaged for travel and portability
- Includes all essentials: bitters, sugar cubes, tools
- Makes a great unique gift
- Refill kits available for sustainability
Good to know
- Alcohol not included
- Some find it a bit pricey for the number of drinks
10. Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries
Check Latest PriceWoodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries are an exquisite garnish that can truly elevate any bourbon cocktail, particularly an Old Fashioned or Manhattan. These deep ruby-red, long-stemmed cherries are handpicked in Oregon and steeped in Woodford Reserve bourbon, imparting a rich, complex flavor that’s both sweet and subtly boozy.
Cocktail connoisseurs consistently rave about how these cherries kick up their Old Fashioned drinks, far outperforming standard maraschino cherries. Many find the flavor to be full-bodied and incredibly delicious, making them a new customer favorite. Beyond cocktails, they’re also enjoyed as a gourmet twist on desserts like vanilla ice cream.
If you’re looking to add a touch of elegance and a significant flavor boost to your bourbon cocktails, these premium cherries are an essential. While they are on the pricier side, the quality and the sophisticated touch they bring to your drinks and desserts absolutely justify the investment for those seeking a top-tier experience.
Why it’s great
- Steeped in Woodford Reserve bourbon
- Rich, complex sweet and boozy flavor
- Elevates classic cocktails like Old Fashioneds
- Delicious as a dessert topping
Good to know
- Higher price point for a garnish
- Some reports of jar leakage during shipping
11. Daniel’s Broiler Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mixer
Check Latest PriceDirect from the renowned Daniel’s Broiler Steakhouse, this Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mixer promises a craft cocktail experience at home. Made in small batches with premium ingredients like fresh lemon, lime, and organic sugar, it aims to deliver a silky, tangy, and consistently flavorful Whiskey Sour.
Many users appreciate the great taste and ease of use, finding it an excellent premix for Whiskey Sours. Some even feel transported back to a speakeasy era, enjoying the strong taste with hints of orange and cherry. The convenience of skipping the prep time while still achieving a quality drink is a big win for busy individuals.
This mixer is an ideal choice for those who love a classic Whiskey Sour and want a restaurant-quality drink without the effort. It’s perfect for casual enjoyment or for impressing guests with a consistently delicious, well-balanced cocktail, embodying cocktail artistry in a bottle.
Why it’s great
- Crafted with premium lemon, lime & organic sugar
- Silky with a tangy finish
- Easy 1:1 mixing ratio
- From a renowned steakhouse brand
Good to know
- Some found the flavor too sour
- One report of brown color, indicating possible spoilage
12. Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix
Check Latest PriceThe Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix is a premium cocktail mixer designed to bring the authentic taste of a classic Old Fashioned directly to your home bar. Expertly crafted with a balance of sweetness and bitterness, it offers a smooth, flavorful drink that’s perfect for any occasion.
Many whiskey lovers consider this mix to be among the best they’ve tried, offering a well-rounded taste profile with cherry, citrus, and bitters. They appreciate its ability to create a good Old Fashioned when time or ingredients for a scratch-made version are limited. The use of pure cane sugar and honey, along with natural flavors, is also a plus for those seeking quality ingredients.
This mix is an excellent choice for anyone who wants a quick and reliable way to make a delicious Old Fashioned. It’s versatile enough for traditional cocktails or experimenting with new whiskey-based recipes, making it a convenient and flavorful staple for your home bar.
Why it’s great
- Authentic bar-quality taste
- Made with pure cane sugar and honey
- Non-GMO and natural flavors
- Versatile for various whiskey drinks
Good to know
- Specific flavor intensity can be subjective
- Bottle size is smaller than some competitors
13. Master of Mixes Old Fashioned Drink Mix
Check Latest PriceMaster of Mixes Old Fashioned Drink Mix offers a convenient and affordable way to enjoy this classic cocktail. This ready-to-use blend combines dark, sweet cherry juice, tangy California orange juice, simple syrup, and aromatic bitters, aiming to elevate your spirits with minimal fuss.
Regular consumers of Old Fashioneds often find this mix to be a good value for the money, making a decent drink without much effort. Many appreciate the convenience of simply adding bourbon and ice. While some note it can be a little sweet, they suggest adjusting the ratio of mix to bourbon to suit individual taste preferences for a more balanced cocktail.
This mix is an excellent option for those seeking an easy, budget-friendly way to enjoy an Old Fashioned regularly. It’s perfect for casual home use, especially if you’re looking to take the work out of making the drink and just want to add your quality bourbon for a quick, satisfying cocktail.
Why it’s great
- Convenient ready-to-use format
- Good value for the price
- Gluten-free and dairy-free
- Versatile for bourbon or brandy
Good to know
- Can be overly sweet for some palates
- May require ratio adjustment for optimal taste
14. Fee Brothers Old Fashion Cocktail Bitters
Check Latest PriceFee Brothers Old Fashion Cocktail Bitters are a staple for any serious home bartender, adding depth, balance, and complexity to a wide variety of drinks. Blended from fine ingredients, these highly aromatic bitters are essential for crafting classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned and countless innovative creations.
Cocktail aficionados frequently describe these as “grandpa’s bitters,” noting their rich citrus and floral aromatics that enhance spirits without overpowering them. Many find that just a few dashes make their Old Fashioned cocktails taste like they came from a five-star restaurant. They are also appreciated for being vegan-friendly and gluten-free.
These bitters are a foundational component for anyone looking to build authentic and sophisticated bourbon cocktails from scratch. They are perfect for mixologists who enjoy fine-tuning their drinks and adding a savory zest that elevates the entire drinking experience, making them a timeless bar essential.
Why it’s great
- Adds depth, balance, and complexity
- Vegan-friendly and gluten-free
- Family-owned since 1864
- Enhances classic and innovative cocktails
Good to know
- Some prefer a stronger, more intense flavor
- Requires other ingredients for a full cocktail
15. Bar-Tenders Instant Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mix
Check Latest PriceBar-Tenders Instant Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mix offers an incredibly convenient and portable way to enjoy a classic Whiskey Sour. Each box contains 8 individually sealed pouches, making it effortless to whip up a refreshing cocktail with just whiskey and water, anywhere you go.
Long-time users and new fans alike consistently praise this mix for its authentic flavor and ease of preparation, noting it lacks the “weird or fake taste” often found in other powdered mixes. Many appreciate its ability to create a nice foamy top when shaken well, a hallmark of a true Whiskey Sour. It’s a cherished product for home entertaining, camping, boating, and travel.
If you’re looking for a reliable, tasty, and highly portable Whiskey Sour solution, this powdered mix is an excellent choice. It’s perfect for those who want quick, consistent results without compromising on flavor, making it a staple for impromptu cocktails at home or on any adventure.
Why it’s great
- Authentic sweet and tart flavor
- Quick and easy individual pouches
- Highly portable for travel and outdoors
- Versatile for bourbon, rye, or mocktails
Good to know
- Can be harder to find in stores
- Some prefer liquid sour mixes for texture
Understanding the Specs
Mixer Type
Mixers come in various forms: liquid concentrates (like syrups or ready-to-use blends), powdered mixes for portability, bitters for aromatic complexity, and infusion kits for DIY flavor creation. Each type offers different levels of convenience and control over your final drink. Liquid options are often the easiest, while bitters and kits allow for more customization.
Ingredients & Flavor Profile
The core of any great mixer lies in its ingredients. Look for natural fruit juices (lemon, lime, cherry, orange), pure cane sugar, and authentic aromatic bitters. Some mixers incorporate spices (cinnamon, clove, allspice) or unique botanicals (ginger, kumquat) to create distinct flavor profiles. Understanding these components helps you choose a mixer that complements your preferred bourbon and taste.
FAQ
What’s the difference between an Old Fashioned mix and a Whiskey Sour mix?
Can I use these mixers for other spirits besides bourbon?
Do I need special equipment to use these mixers?
Are these mixers alcoholic?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most people, the best mixers for bourbon winner is the Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix because it delivers an unparalleled, consistent bar-quality Old Fashioned with minimal effort. If you want an award-winning, organic option, grab the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix. And for a unique, smoky dimension to your drinks, nothing beats the Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch.
