A well-organized kitchen is a joy to cook in, and often, the unsung hero of that organization is your trash can. But when you’re trying to manage both general waste and recyclables, a single bin simply won’t cut it. That’s where dual compartment trash cans step in, offering a streamlined solution to keep your kitchen tidy and your eco-conscious efforts effortless.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind KitchPrep. My 15+ years of expertise in kitchen equipment comes from rigorously analyzing thousands of user reviews, comparing hundreds of models, and studying industry data on durability and odor control.
Choosing the right bin can make a surprising difference in your daily routine, from preventing odors to simplifying your recycling habits. To ensure your kitchen remains tidy and functional, our comprehensive guide meticulously evaluates the features and performance of the best dual compartment trash can options available today.
How To Choose The Best Dual Compartment Trash Can
Selecting the ideal dual compartment trash can involves more than just picking a pretty design. Consider these factors to ensure your choice truly enhances your kitchen’s efficiency and cleanliness.
Capacity and Dimensions
The size of your household and the amount of waste and recycling you generate daily will dictate the ideal capacity. For a single person or small family, a 40-50 liter (10-13 gallon) total capacity might suffice, while larger families might need 60 liters (16 gallons) or more. Always measure your available kitchen space, especially under counters or in narrow nooks, to ensure the bin fits without obstructing movement or cabinet doors.
Material and Durability
Dual compartment trash cans come in various materials, each with its own benefits. Stainless steel offers a sleek, modern look and is highly durable, often featuring fingerprint-resistant finishes for easy maintenance. Plastic options are typically lighter, more affordable, and can be easier to clean, though they may not offer the same premium aesthetic or long-term resilience. Consider how often you’ll be interacting with the bin and how important aesthetics are to your kitchen design.
Opening Mechanism and Features
Hands-free operation, usually via a foot pedal or motion sensor, is a popular feature for obvious hygienic reasons. Look for smooth, quiet-closing lids that prevent slamming and potential damage. Some models offer a “stay-open” lid function for longer tasks like meal prep. Inner bins that are easy to remove and clean, along with features like bag cinches or deodorizer compartments, can significantly improve the user experience and overall hygiene.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Type | Best For | Key Feature | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EKO EcoCasa II | Stainless Steel | Overall Value | Engineered for 200,000+ Steps | AmazonCheck Price |
| simplehuman 58 Liter | Stainless Steel | Premium Functionality | Liner Rim System & Pocket | AmazonCheck Price |
| Joseph Joseph Totem Compact | Aluminum/Plastic | Space-Saving Vertical | Integrated Food Waste Caddy | AmazonCheck Price |
| SONGMICS Trash Can ULTB741G01 | Steel/PP Plastic | Modern Kitchen Aesthetics | Sleek Slate Gray Finish | AmazonCheck Price |
| EKO Vintage 50L Motion Sensor | Stainless Steel | Touchless Operation | Lightning-Fast 0.2-sec Sensor | AmazonCheck Price |
| simplehuman 40 Liter Butterfly | Stainless Steel | Low Countertop Fit | Split Butterfly Lid | AmazonCheck Price |
| Amazon Basics Dual Compartment | Stainless Steel | Dependable Performance | Fingerprint-Proof Finish | AmazonCheck Price |
| SUPER DEAL Kitchen Trash Can | Stainless Steel | Generous Capacity | 16 Gallon Extra Large | AmazonCheck Price |
| SONGMICS Trash Can ULTB60NL | Stainless Steel | Robust & Silent | Powder-Coated Steel Body | AmazonCheck Price |
| SIMPLI-MAGIC 60 Liter | Stainless Steel | Integrated Odor Filter | Built-in Charcoal Filter | AmazonCheck Price |
| Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 Gallon | Plastic | Compact & Affordable | Push-Top & Step Pedal Access | AmazonCheck Price |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. EKO EcoCasa II 36L+24L Dual Trash Can
Check Latest PriceThe EKO EcoCasa II stands out as our top pick for its exceptional blend of capacity, durability, and thoughtful design. With a generous 60-liter (16-gallon) total capacity split into 36L and 24L compartments, it offers ample space for both trash and recycling without feeling overly bulky. Crafted from fingerprint-resistant stainless steel, this bin is built to withstand the rigors of a busy kitchen while maintaining a sleek, polished appearance.
Home managers and culinary enthusiasts consistently praise its robust construction, with the foot pedal engineered to endure over 200,000 step cycles, ensuring long-term reliability. The whisper-soft close lids are a standout feature, preventing disruptive noise and effectively locking in odors to keep your kitchen fresh. Many appreciate the ergonomic side handles for easy repositioning and the sturdy carry handles on the removable inner buckets, making waste disposal a mess-free task.
This bin is ideal for families or anyone seeking a high-quality, long-lasting solution for waste separation. Its solid build and convenient features make daily trash and recycling management feel less like a chore and more like a seamless part of your kitchen routine. It’s a true workhorse designed for longevity and ease of use.
Why it’s great
- High capacity (60L total) for busy households.
- Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel for easy maintenance.
- Foot pedal engineered for extreme durability (200,000+ steps).
- Whisper-soft close lids effectively contain odors.
- Removable inner buckets with sturdy carry handles.
Good to know
- Inner bins are slim, requiring careful bag placement.
- Some users note that standard 13-gallon bags may not reach the very bottom.
- Potential for dents during shipping, though packaging has improved.
2. simplehuman 58 Liter Dual Compartment Recycling Step Can
Check Latest PriceThe simplehuman 58 Liter Dual Compartment Recycling Step Can redefines waste management with its innovative features and superior build quality. This model boasts a unique liner rim system that lifts for easy bag changes and then closes over the liner to keep it neatly out of sight, a design choice that adds both aesthetics and hygiene. Its 15.3-gallon capacity is intelligently divided, with a plastic bucket for recycling and a liner pocket in the trash compartment.
Many discerning users rave about the “liner pocket” feature, which stores a 20-pack of custom-fit liners right inside the can, dispensing them one by one for effortless changes. This attention to detail, coupled with a strong steel pedal engineered for longevity and a soft-close plastic lid, creates a truly premium experience. Homeowners appreciate the increased internal space (25% more room for trash due to the absence of a bulky inner bucket on the trash side) and the fingerprint-resistant brushed stainless steel finish.
This simplehuman model is a perfect fit for those who prioritize seamless functionality and a clean, integrated look in their kitchen. It’s an investment in convenience, designed to make daily waste sorting a discreet and highly efficient process, particularly for those who prefer dedicated, custom-fit liners.
Why it’s great
- Unique liner rim system hides bags and simplifies changes.
- Integrated liner pocket stores and dispenses bags.
- 25% more internal capacity without an inner bucket on one side.
- Durable steel pedal and soft-close lid.
- Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish.
Good to know
- Requires custom-fit simplehuman liners for optimal bag fit.
- Premium price point.
- Some users reported minor dents upon delivery.
3. Joseph Joseph Totem Compact 40 Liter Waste Separation and Recycling Kitchen Trash Bin
Check Latest PriceThe Joseph Joseph Totem Compact 40 Liter offers an ingenious vertical design that maximizes waste and recycling capacity in minimal floor space. This second-generation model features two stacked compartments – a 5.3-gallon general waste section at the top and a 5.3-gallon multi-purpose recycling drawer at the base. Its unique structure is particularly advantageous for smaller kitchens or areas where horizontal space is at a premium.
Users frequently highlight the integrated 0.8-gallon removable food waste caddy as a game-changer, which can be stored within either main compartment or conveniently on the countertop. The inclusion of a replaceable carbon filter in the lid is also a highly valued feature, effectively combating unpleasant odors. Many appreciate the smooth operation of the top lid, opening gently with a light press, and the recycling drawer that glides out effortlessly on wheels.
This bin is an excellent choice for individuals or small families focused on efficient waste separation, especially those who prioritize composting. Its clever vertical layout and thoughtful additions like the odor filter and compost caddy make it a highly functional and aesthetically pleasing solution for modern, compact living spaces, justifying its premium price for the organizational benefits it provides.
Why it’s great
- Space-saving vertical design with stacked compartments.
- Includes a convenient removable food waste caddy.
- Replaceable carbon filter for effective odor control.
- Smooth-gliding recycling drawer with wheels.
- Each compartment has removable buckets and bag breather vents.
Good to know
- Higher price point.
- Food waste caddy lid can be loose, potentially letting smells out.
- Optimal fit with Joseph Joseph custom bags, which can be pricey.
4. SONGMICS Trash Can, 2 x 8 Gallon (2 x 30 L) Dual-Compartment Garbage Can ULTB741G01
Check Latest PriceThe SONGMICS ULTB741G01 brings a touch of elegance to waste management with its sleek slate gray appearance and harmonious design. This dual-compartment bin offers a substantial 2 x 8 gallon (60L total) capacity, providing ample space for sorting both trash and recyclables. Its clean lines and subtle matte finish allow it to seamlessly blend into modern kitchen décors, making it feel less like a utility item and more like a thoughtful design element.
Home chefs and design-conscious individuals frequently commend its robust construction from quality stainless steel, ensuring lasting strength. The soft-close lid operates smoothly and silently, preventing disruptive noises, and can even be manually lifted to a 90° stay-open position for extended tasks. The two removable inner bins simplify disposal and cleaning, and many users appreciate the integrated bag holes that keep liners securely in place, minimizing slippage and maintaining a tidy appearance.
This trash can is an ideal choice for those who value both aesthetics and functionality in their kitchen appliances. Its generous capacity, coupled with its elegant design and practical features, makes it a highly recommended option for maintaining a clean and stylish home environment without compromise.
Why it’s great
- Elegant slate gray design complements modern kitchens.
- Robust stainless steel construction for durability.
- Soft-close lid with a stay-open feature.
- Dual removable liners with bag holes for secure fitting.
- Spacious 16-gallon total capacity.
Good to know
- Bags may show slightly if not tucked in well.
- Inner bins are 8 gallons, which might be smaller than some expect for recycling.
- Pedal-only opening, no motion sensor.
5. EKO Vintage 50L / 13.2 Gallon Motion Sensor Trash Can
Check Latest PriceThe EKO Vintage 50L Motion Sensor Trash Can brings touchless convenience and smart waste sorting to your kitchen. Equipped with a lightning-fast 0.2-second sensor, this bin offers a seamless, hands-free experience, ideal for when your hands are full or messy during meal preparation. Its dual compartment design thoughtfully separates an 8.45-gallon bin for everyday waste and a 4.75-gallon bin for recyclables, all within a compact footprint.
Busy parents and tech-savvy homeowners appreciate the whisper-quiet soft-close lid, which adds to the peaceful kitchen environment and helps contain odors. The liner-free interior maximizes internal volume, offering up to 25% more capacity, and the fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish ensures it stays looking clean and stylish. Many users highlight its impressive battery life, providing up to 8 months of use on just 4 AA alkaline batteries, a testament to its efficient design.
This touchless trash can is perfect for those seeking ultimate hygiene and modern convenience. Its reliable motion sensor, efficient capacity, and sleek, durable build make it a standout choice for any contemporary kitchen, especially where minimizing contact with surfaces is a priority.
Why it’s great
- Fast and reliable motion sensor for touchless operation.
- Whisper-quiet soft-close lid.
- Maximized internal volume with liner-free design.
- Long-lasting battery life (up to 8 months).
- Durable, fingerprint-resistant stainless steel.
Good to know
- Does not use removable inner bins, only a bag ring.
- Recycling compartment is smaller (4.75 gallons).
- Motion sensor can be sensitive to accidental triggers.
6. simplehuman 40 Liter / 10.6 Gallon Dual Compartment Butterfly Lid Kitchen Recycling Step Trash Can
Check Latest PriceThe simplehuman 40 Liter Butterfly Lid Kitchen Recycling Step Trash Can offers a unique solution for kitchens with low countertops or limited overhead clearance. Its distinctive butterfly lid opens from the center, providing maximum clearance and preventing the lid from hitting walls or cabinets. This dual-compartment design efficiently sorts trash and recyclables into two equal 20-liter (5.3-gallon) sections.
Apartment dwellers and those with compact kitchens consistently praise the butterfly lid’s functionality, making it easy to dispose of waste even in tight spaces. The strong steel pedal is engineered for over 150,000 steps, promising two decades of daily use, and the patented lid shox technology ensures a slow, silent close. Users also appreciate the “stay-open” lid feature for longer tasks and the fingerprint-proof finish that keeps the stainless steel looking pristine.
This simplehuman bin is ideal for anyone needing a durable, space-efficient waste solution that fits perfectly under lower countertops. Its robust construction and thoughtful design make it a reliable and aesthetically pleasing choice for streamlined waste separation in smaller kitchens or areas with unique spatial constraints.
Why it’s great
- Butterfly lid design for low countertops.
- Strong steel pedal built for extreme longevity.
- Silent-close lid with stay-open feature.
- Fingerprint-proof stainless steel finish.
- Removable inner buckets for easy cleaning.
Good to know
- Smaller capacity (10.6 gallons total) may require more frequent emptying.
- Requires simplehuman’s custom code D liners for a perfect fit.
- Premium price for its capacity.
7. Amazon Basics Dual Compartment Recycling Trash Can
Check Latest PriceThe Amazon Basics Dual Compartment Recycling Trash Can offers a straightforward and dependable solution for separating waste and recycling in your home. With a total capacity of 60 liters (15.9 gallons) divided into two 7.9-gallon interior plastic liner bins, it provides practical space for daily household needs. Its durable stainless steel exterior is fingerprint-proof and smudge-resistant, ensuring it maintains a clean and sleek appearance with minimal effort.
Homeowners often praise its robust construction and smooth, quiet soft-close lid, which prevents slamming and contributes to a peaceful kitchen environment. The removable liner bins, equipped with handles, make waste disposal and cleaning notably convenient. Many find its size to be just right for fitting at the end of a counter or in smaller rooms, offering good capacity without being overly bulky. The non-slip rubber pads keep the unit securely in place on various flooring types.
This Amazon Basics bin is a solid choice for those seeking reliable performance and good value without unnecessary frills. It’s particularly well-suited for families who need a sturdy, easy-to-clean dual compartment solution that blends seamlessly into most kitchen aesthetics.
Why it’s great
- Good capacity (15.9 gallons total) for everyday use.
- Durable, fingerprint-proof stainless steel exterior.
- Soft-close lid for quiet operation.
- Removable liner bins with handles for easy emptying.
- Non-slip rubber pads keep it stable.
Good to know
- Opening mechanism is manual-lift, not step-on or motion sensor.
- Some users wish the inner bins were slightly larger.
- One reviewer noted inner bin handles can interfere with bag removal.
8. SUPER DEAL Kitchen Trash Can 16 Gallon 60L Dual Stainless Steel
Check Latest PriceThe SUPER DEAL Kitchen Trash Can offers an impressive 16-gallon (60L) extra-large capacity, making it a robust solution for separating dry and wet trash or combining trash and recycling. Its dual compartments, each with an independent lid, work effectively to contain odors, ensuring your kitchen remains fresh. Crafted from high-quality 410 stainless steel, this rectangular bin promises durability and a sleek, modern appearance that complements most home and office decor styles.
Busy households and small businesses praise its sturdy construction and premium manual foot pedals, designed for years of daily use. The removable inner buckets, made from shatter-resistant PP plastic and equipped with strong stainless steel handles, simplify the process of taking out garbage and cleaning. Many users appreciate the quiet and safe slow-close lid mechanism, which prevents accidental injury and maintains a peaceful environment.
This trash can is an excellent choice for those who need significant capacity and durable construction for high-traffic areas. Its minimalist yet stylish design, combined with practical features like easy-to-clean surfaces and odor isolation, makes it a highly functional and long-lasting addition to any kitchen, living room, or office.
Why it’s great
- Extra-large 16-gallon capacity.
- Durable stainless steel 410 body with PP plastic liners.
- Quiet and safe soft-close lids.
- Removable inner bins with strong handles for easy emptying.
- Sleek, modern aesthetic with anti-dent/scratch finish.
Good to know
- Some users find the individual compartments small despite the overall large size.
- Regular trash bags can be hard to keep in place.
- Heavier than some alternatives at 20.5 pounds.
9. SONGMICS Trash Can, 2 x 8 Gallon (2 x 30 L) Garbage Can ULTB60NL
Check Latest PriceThe SONGMICS ULTB60NL offers a sturdy and aesthetically pleasing solution for kitchen waste, combining silver and black colors with a simple silhouette to be an eye-catcher. This 16-gallon (60L) dual compartment bin is designed for hands-free operation via a foot pedal, allowing you to easily dispose of waste even when your hands are full. Its robust stainless steel body is built for long-lasting use, ensuring durability in a busy kitchen environment.
Home cooks and busy families appreciate the soft-close lid, which ensures a peaceful environment by preventing loud slamming. The inclusion of two removable inner buckets makes cleaning effortless, especially if a trash bag accidentally breaks. Many users find the size perfect for separating garbage and recycling, and the inner handles on the buckets are a smart design feature, allowing for safe transport of overly-full bags without spillage. The stainless steel maintains its shine and resists fingerprints, making it easy to wipe clean.
This SONGMICS trash can is an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable, well-designed dual compartment bin that offers both functionality and a modern look. Its sturdy build, quiet operation, and easy maintenance make it a valuable addition to any kitchen or high-traffic area, promising years of dependable service.
Why it’s great
- Eye-catching silver and black design.
- Hands-free foot pedal operation.
- Rigid stainless steel body built for longevity.
- Soft-close lid for a peaceful environment.
- Two removable buckets with inner handles for easy cleaning.
Good to know
- Lid is black plastic, not stainless steel, which some find less premium.
- Inner bins are smaller than a standard kitchen trash can, requiring more frequent emptying.
- Standard 13-gallon bags may be too large and difficult to tuck neatly.
10. SIMPLI-MAGIC 60 Liter / 16 Gallon Rectangular Hands-Free Dual Compartment Recycling Kitchen Step Trash Can
Check Latest PriceThe SIMPLI-MAGIC 60 Liter Dual Compartment Recycling Kitchen Step Trash Can is designed to offer a high-capacity waste and recycling solution with a focus on odor control. Its color-coded liners (Green 30L and Black 30L) facilitate easy sorting without sacrificing overall capacity, fitting standard liners with a convenient bag cinch. The brushed stainless steel finish naturally hides fingerprints and smudges, maintaining a clean appearance in your kitchen.
Homeowners appreciate the hands-free stainless steel foot pedal, which stands up to daily use and keeps hands clean during disposal. A standout feature is the built-in filter for odor control, a welcome addition for keeping kitchen smells at bay. The slow-close lid ensures quiet operation, and an extended open lid lock is perfect for longer tasks, allowing the container to stay open when needed. Users found the bag cinches and a small hook inside helpful for securing trash bags, preventing them from slipping down.
This bin is an excellent choice for families who generate a fair amount of waste and prioritize effective odor management. Its practical features, combined with a durable and low-maintenance design, make it a reliable and hygienic addition to any kitchen looking to streamline its waste and recycling efforts.
Why it’s great
- High 16-gallon capacity with color-coded liners.
- Built-in filter for effective odor control.
- Hands-free foot pedal and slow-close lid.
- Extended open lid lock for convenience during tasks.
- Brushed stainless steel finish resists fingerprints.
Good to know
- Some users reported issues with the slow-close mechanism breaking.
- Can be challenging to get regular trash bags to fit and stay securely.
- Lacks labels for trash/recycling, requiring user-added stickers.
11. Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 Gallon, Dual Trash and Recycling Bin
Check Latest PriceThe Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 Gallon Dual Trash and Recycling Bin offers a compact and affordable solution for basic waste separation. With two 5.5-gallon (20-liter) removable bins, it provides a total of 11 gallons of capacity, making it suitable for smaller spaces or households with lower waste generation. Its plastic construction makes it lightweight and easy to clean, a practical choice for everyday use.
Budget-conscious consumers and those with limited space appreciate its dual opening mechanisms: spring-top buttons for individual bin access and a hands-free step pedal for opening both lids simultaneously. The slow-close lid function is a welcome feature, preventing slamming. Many users find it easy to remove the inner bins thanks to their large handles, and its compact dimensions allow it to fit perfectly in smaller areas, even helping kids learn to sort waste.
This bin is an excellent option for individuals, small families, or as a secondary bin in areas like offices or pool areas. While its capacity is smaller than some, its affordability, ease of use, and compact design make it a practical and functional choice for basic dual waste management without a hefty price tag.
Why it’s great
- Affordable price point.
- Dual opening mechanisms: push-top and step pedal.
- Slow-close lid function.
- Lightweight and easy to clean plastic construction.
- Compact size fits well in smaller spaces.
Good to know
- Smaller total capacity (11 gallons).
- Inner bins are narrow, which can make bag removal difficult when full.
- Some reports of durability issues with the plastic construction.
Understanding the Specs
Capacity (Liters/Gallons)
This refers to the total volume the trash can can hold, usually expressed in liters or gallons. For dual compartment bins, this is the sum of both compartments. A larger capacity means less frequent emptying, but also a larger footprint. Consider your household size and waste generation habits.
Opening Mechanism
This describes how the lid opens. Common mechanisms include step-on (foot pedal), motion-sensor (touchless), and manual-lift. Each offers different levels of convenience and hygiene. Step-on pedals are durable and hands-free, motion sensors offer ultimate touchless operation, and manual-lift is simplest but requires touching the lid.
FAQ
Why should I get a dual compartment trash can?
What size dual compartment trash can do I need?
Are dual compartment trash cans good for odor control?
Can I use regular trash bags with these bins?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most people, the best dual compartment trash can winner is the EKO EcoCasa II 36L+24L Dual Trash Can because of its exceptional durability, generous capacity, and reliable odor control. If you want premium functionality with innovative bag management, grab the simplehuman 58 Liter Dual Compartment Recycling Step Can. And for space-saving vertical design with an integrated compost caddy, nothing beats the Joseph Joseph Totem Compact 40 Liter Waste Separation and Recycling Kitchen Trash Bin.
