Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Finding a frame for the odd 19×23 inch size is a frustrating hunt, but the right one transforms a plain print into a focal point. This guide breaks down the eight best options, from budget-friendly engineered wood to premium real reclaimed barnwood, so you can match the frame to your art and your wall. It’s built on the makers’ published specs and what verified buyers actually experience in their own homes.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind KitchPrep. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
One note before we start: a few listings here use slightly flexible matching, so the nearest same-type size serves the same purpose as an exact 19×23. Here is the honest breakdown of the best 19×23 frame options, ranked for quality, value, and real-world owner satisfaction.
Our Picks at a Glance
How To Choose The Best 19X23 Frame
Before you click buy, you need to know your art’s thickness and your wall’s style. A 19×23 frame is a specific size, but the depth of the frame and the material it’s made from will decide if it works for your poster, canvas, or diploma.
Framing Material: Real Wood vs. Engineered Wood
Real wood frames, like the reclaimed barnwood option, bring a unique texture and character that engineered wood can’t match, but they are heavier and pricier. Engineered wood frames, like MDF, are lighter on your wall and easier on your budget, but they won’t have the natural grain of solid timber.
Depth and Rabbet: Will Your Art Fit?
The “rabbet” is the space behind the lip of the frame that holds your art. A thicker matted print or a wrapped canvas needs a deeper rabbet, so check that measurement in inches before you commit. For a standard poster or photo, a shallower frame is fine and looks sleeker on the wall.
Front Cover: Acrylic vs. Glass
Acrylic fronts are shatterproof and lighter than glass, which is a big safety win for large frames in busy rooms. The trade-off is that acrylic scratches more easily than glass, so you have to be careful when cleaning it.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Frame Material | Front Cover | Item Weight | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Craig Frames 19×23★ Best Overall | Rustic decor on a budget | Engineered Wood | Acrylic | — | Amazon |
| ArtToFrames Soft BlackBest Value | A versatile custom poster frame | Engineered Wood | Acrylic | 3.8 pounds | Amazon |
| ArtToFrames CoffeeClassic Choice | A classic look with real glass | Engineered Wood | Glass | 9 pounds | Amazon |
| wallsthatspeak Black | A durable shatterproof frame | Wood | Acrylic | — | Amazon |
| CustomPictureFrames.com Noir | A precise, handcrafted black frame | Wood | Acrylic | — | Amazon |
| CustomPictureFrames.com Horizontal | Landscape-oriented art | Wood | Acrylic | — | Amazon |
| BARNWOODUSA Weathered Gray | Authentic reclaimed wood character | Wood | Acrylic | — | Amazon |
In-Depth Reviews
1. Craig Frames 19×23 White Picture Frame
Our pick — over 4.5★ from 850+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
The rustic white frame delivers a premium look at a mid-range price.
The 2-inch wide flat antique white frame gives your poster a substantial, gallery-worthy presence. The distressed finish is engineered wood, but buyers consistently note it reads as weathered barnwood, with the kind of smooth, splinter-free surface you expect from a pricier piece.
This frame shines for a 16×20 canvas — buyers report it fits that size perfectly — while its 22.5″L x 26.5″W finished dimensions frame the 19×23 print with a generous border. The included wire hanging kit is meant for horizontal display, so it’s a natural fit for landscapes and wide panoramas, though installation is required on your end.
What wins people over is the value: the review pages sum it up as “excellent price,” and happy customers who own it in other sizes are already planning to repurchase. It’s a mid-range price for a look that photographs like a custom barnwood build, which is why it takes our top spot.
What shines here
- 2-inch wide flat profile creates a bold, substantial look
- Rustic white finish is smooth, with no splinters or color mismatches
- Fits a 16×20 canvas perfectly in a 19×23 opening
Keep in mind
- Uses acrylic, which scratches more easily than glass
- Hanging kit is for horizontal display only
The pick for: anyone wanting a rustic farmhouse look with a designer-approved finish, especially for landscape prints and 16×20 canvases.
Think twice if: you need a glass front for maximum clarity and scratch resistance, since this uses plastic.
2. ArtToFrames 19×23 Inch Soft Black Custom Poster Frame
The budget-friendly frame handles odd sizes and thick art with ease.
You get a sturdy, well-built frame that owners mention looks pricier than it is — the quality is the top praise in owner feedback. It’s engineered wood with a soft black finish, made to order in the USA, so you can request custom sizes easily.
Fit is where this one flexes: the 0.4375 inch rabbet (the gap between the lip and the back, or the thickest art it can hold) is deep enough for a dimensional print or a custom towel, buyers confirmed. At 3.8 pounds, it’s lighter than the 9-pound Coffee option from the same brand, so hanging is easier, though its finished size of 21″L x 25″W is more compact than the Craig Frames pick’s 22.5″L x 26.5″W.
The honest catch is the included hanging hardware. The wire is too short for secure ties and the nail is too small for the frame’s size and weight, creating a risk of it falling — a recurring buyer note. Plan to use your own stronger wire and nail, and you’ve got a superb value frame.
Smart buy for: anyone framing a textured print, poster, or non-standard item who wants a custom look without the custom price tag.
Plan ahead: swap the included wire and nail for sturdier hardware, since the stock set is the weakest link.
3. ArtToFrames 19×23 Inch Coffee MDF Poster Frame
A deep, heavy frame with real glass gives your art a polished, premium finish.
For crisp glass over your print, this Coffee-colored MDF frame delivers — at 9 pounds, it’s 2.4x heavier than the soft black ArtToFrames option, so it’s built with substantial materials. The flat profile is 1.25 inches wide, and the glass fits snugly, with owners calling the inside measurements exact.
The deep 0.3750 inch rabbet means it can hold slightly thicker art, though customers note the tabs can feel tight with matted or thick images. It hangs easily and looks great — one owner framed a Taylor Swift poster and was “highly impressed,” while others framed pictures that fit perfectly and loved the look on their walls.
The trade-offs are practical: the backing is a thin white cardboard, and it may be slightly short in length by about 1/4 inch for some, a mixed point in the size feedback. Also, the sawtooth hanger requires self-installation, so it’s not quite ready to hang from the start.
What wins people over
- Real glass front offers crisp, scratch-resistant clarity
- Heavy 9-pound build feels substantial and durable
- Sleek flat profile looks great with posters and prints
The honest trade-offs
- Backing is a thin cardboard, not a rigid board
- A few reviewers point out the length runs about 1/4 inch short
Reach for this if: you want the crisp look of glass and a sturdy, weighty frame for a permanent wall display.
Look elsewhere if: you need the lightest possible frame, since at 9 pounds this is a heavy unit.
4. wallsthatspeak 19×23 Black Picture Frame
The eco-friendly black frame with a shatterproof front offers a premium look at a budget price.
The standout spec here is the rigid plexiglass front, which is durable and shatterproof — a real safety win for a large frame in a hallway or kids’ room. It’s built from BonanzaWood, an eco-friendly composite that gives you the finish of solid wood at a fraction of the price, with a very smooth brushed black surface.
At 1.25 inches wide on the top surface and sitting 0.75 inches off the wall, it has a clean, modern profile that owners say looks expensive. It’s a go-to for the 19×23 size that’s so hard to find — one reviewer noted they “finally found it here” after searching everywhere, and others say it’s perfect for a 15×30 poster print.
The caveat is the uninstalled sawtooth hanger, which you’ll need to attach yourself, and the occasional shipping damage report where corner gaps or flimsy backing showed up. It hangs vertically or horizontally, so you’re covered either way, and the lightweight build makes installation easy.
Great for: buyers wanting a safe, shatterproof frame for high-traffic areas who value an expensive look from an eco-friendly material.
Watch for: a rare delivery unit with minor corner or backing imperfections, so check it over on arrival.
5. CustomPictureFrames.com 19×23 Noir Classique Frame
A handcrafted black wood frame with UV protection that shields your art from fading.
The defining advantage here is the UV-resistant acrylic front, which protects your photos, diplomas, or kids’ drawings from sun damage over time — a feature you don’t get on cheaper frames. This 0.75 inch wide moulding with a 0.5 inch rabbet depth is handcrafted from real wood, polished black, and custom made to order in the USA.
It’s a favorite among cross-stitch crafters who struggle to find odd sizes, with owners noting it’s a reasonable price versus local custom framing shops and that the plexiglass comes with a protective film that aids assembly. The overall frame dimensions measure 20.5″ x 24.5″, a slightly tighter footprint than the ArtToFrames options.
The trade-off is the foam board backing, which is on the thin side, and the metal back holders that feel a bit flimsy to some. It’s a premium price, but for a piece that protects your art from UV rays and is made to order in the USA, crafters say it’s worth it.
Best for: protecting valuable prints, certificates, or handmade crafts from fading, with a precise handcrafted black wood build.
Minor quibbles: the foam backing is thin and the back holders feel a little light, so handle them gently.
6. CustomPictureFrames.com 23×19 Noir Classique Frame
The landscape-oriented twin is purpose-built for wide panoramas and diamond paintings.
This is the horizontal version of the same handcrafted Noir Classique line, measuring 23×19 inches with overall dimensions of 24.5″ x 20.5″. It’s the same 0.75 inch wide real wood moulding with a 0.5 inch depth, but the landscape orientation makes it the obvious pick for wide-format art like panorama photos or wide diamond paintings.
Owners use it for everything from a Monet exhibit print to diamond paintings, noting it saved them from spending + on a custom frame. The UV-resistant acrylic and acid-free foam board backing come complete in the box, and the packaging is solid, per buyers. The hanging hardware is included but not installed, so you can set it for either orientation, though this one is meant for horizontal display.
The honest note is the mixed value feedback — it’s a premium price, and some owners say you pay for what you get, while others mention fragility during shipping. For a handcrafted, made-to-order USA frame in a hard-to-find size, the quality is consistently praised.
What owners love
- Perfect for landscape-oriented art like panoramas and wide prints
- Saves serious money versus custom framing services
- Solid packaging protects the frame in transit
Weigh this
- Premium price at the high end of the 19×23 spectrum
- An occasional unit arrives with fragility issues
Choose this for: wide-format art and diamond paintings where you want a handcrafted, real wood frame without the custom-shop bill.
skip it if: you’re framing a portrait-oriented print, since this is built for horizontal display.
7. BARNWOODUSA 19×23 Natural Weathered Gray Frame
Authentic reclaimed barn wood looks like it came straight off an old structure.
This is the real deal: crafted from actual reclaimed wood, with natural imperfections like nail holes, knots, and splinters that make each piece unique. It “literally looks like it came off an old barn,” as owners put it, and the weathered gray finish adds a genuine farmhouse accent to any room.
This signature series has a raised outside border and chunky 1.5-inch-wide molding. With an outside dimension of 22″ x 26″ and a 19×23 opening, it’s ready to display — the plexiglass front, cardboard backing, and sawtooth hangers are included, so you just insert your photo and mount it portrait or landscape.
The trade-off is the price at, making it the most expensive pick here, and the real wood means real imperfections — if you want a perfectly smooth surface, this isn’t it. But for a custom-size rustic frame that supports American craftsmanship, buyers are thrilled with the quality and the look.
Worth it for: anyone chasing an authentic, one-of-a-kind rustic farmhouse look that commissioned custom shops can’t beat on price.
Expect this: genuine wood character — knots, nail holes, and splinters are part of the charm, not defects.
Understanding the Specs
Rabbet Depth
This is the space between the lip of the frame and the back, measured in inches, and it decides the maximum thickness of art the frame can hold. A thicker wrapped canvas or a matted print needs a deeper rabbet; if your art is too thick, it simply won’t sit flush in the frame. For a standard poster or photo, a shallower depth is perfectly fine and keeps the frame profile slim.
Frame Opening vs. Finished Size
The “opening” is the size of the art it fits, like 19×23, while the “finished size” is the total outside dimension of the frame itself, which is larger. This matters because you need to know the finished size to plan wall space and ensure it fits your layout. Always check both numbers before buying so you’re not surprised by how big the frame actually is on your wall.
Acrylic vs. Glass Fronts
Acrylic fronts are shatterproof and lighter than glass, making them safer for large frames in busy areas like hallways or kids’ rooms, and they’re easier to hang. The trade-off is that acrylic scratches more easily than glass, so you’ll want to clean it with a soft, dry cloth. Glass offers superior scratch resistance and clarity but adds weight and a breakage risk.
Real Wood vs. Engineered Wood
Real wood frames are heavier, more durable, and have a natural texture that engineered wood can’t imitate, though they cost more. Engineered woods like MDF are lighter and budget-friendly, but they won’t have the authentic grain of solid timber. Your choice here is about balancing your budget against the look and heft you want on your wall.
FAQ
What is the difference between a 19×23 frame size and a 23×19 frame size?
Will a 19×23 frame fit a 16×20 canvas?
How much does a 19×23 picture frame weigh?
What is the difference between the frame opening and the finished size?
Is acrylic or glass better for a 19×23 frame?
How do I know if my thick poster will fit in a 19×23 frame?
Can these frames hang both vertically and horizontally?
Are 19×23 frames made of real wood or just plastic?
What’s the best 19×23 frame for a shatterproof front?
Do these frames come with hanging hardware included?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
Across the board, the 19×23 frame winner is the Craig Frames 19×23 White because it delivers a premium rustic look at a mid-range price, and owners consistently say it looks far more expensive than it is. If you want a shatterproof safety pick for a busy home, grab the wallsthatspeak Black. And for authentic reclaimed wood character that’s impossible to fake, the BARNWOODUSA Weathered Gray is the one to reach for.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of September 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, KitchPrep earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.
Related Guides
