Best Small Potatoes For Roasting | Skip Soggy Batches

Small yellow potatoes, fingerlings, and little reds roast up crisp outside and creamy inside, making them the top picks for oven roasting.

The best small potatoes for roasting are usually baby yellow potatoes, fingerlings, and small red potatoes. They brown well, cook fast, and stay creamy in the middle. If you want one easy default, grab small yellow potatoes first.

Still, there isn’t one single winner for every tray. Some small potatoes stay neat and waxy. Some turn fluffy and rough around the edges. The right pick depends on the texture you want on the plate.

What Makes A Small Potato Roast Well

Great roasted potatoes need color on the outside and a tender bite inside. Small potatoes have a head start. Their higher skin-to-flesh ratio means more browned surface in every bite, and their size helps them cook before the outsides dry out.

Here’s what separates a strong roasting potato from a dull one:

• Thin skin: Thin skins crisp faster and don’t need peeling.
• Balanced starch: A little starch builds crust. Too much can make the centers fluffy before the outsides are done.
• Similar size: Even sizing keeps half the pan from burning while the rest stays pale.
• Firm flesh: Smaller waxy types hold their shape and stay creamy after roasting.

Starch level matters more than color. A waxy potato stays smooth and holds together. A floury potato breaks open more easily and gives you those craggy, crisp bits many people love. You just want to match the potato to the result you want.

Best Small Potatoes For Roasting By Type

Small yellow potatoes are the safest buy for most home cooks. They roast with a thin crust and a buttery, creamy center. They also take seasoning well, so olive oil, salt, pepper, garlic, rosemary, paprika, lemon zest, or grated Parmesan all work.

Small red potatoes come next. They’re a little waxier, so they stay firmer after roasting. That makes them a smart pick when you want clean halves in a salad bowl, next to roast chicken, or tucked around a pan of sausages.

Fingerlings are the sleeper hit. Their shape gives you more cut surface when you split them lengthwise, and their flavor runs nuttier than many standard baby potatoes. They’re a strong choice when appearance matters and you want the tray to look as good as it tastes.

Petite white potatoes work well too. They’re mild and roast evenly, though they don’t bring quite as much character as yellows or fingerlings. If the store has only small whites in good shape, they’ll still give you a solid tray if you season them well and leave enough room on the pan.

Baby russets are the outlier. They can roast beautifully, but the texture shifts more toward fluffy than creamy. If you love crisp, rough edges and don’t mind a drier center, they’re a smart pick. If you want a creamy bite, stick with yellow, red, or fingerling types instead.

Blue and purple baby potatoes are fun for mixed roasts. Their flavor can be earthy and their flesh stays fairly firm. They shine in a mixed medley where color matters and you want the tray to feel a little less ordinary.

One useful label note: “new potatoes” are not a separate breed. It usually means potatoes harvested young, so they’re smaller, moist, and thin-skinned. That’s why they roast tender and fast, but they won’t always brown as deeply as a slightly more mature yellow or fingerling potato.

How To Pick The Right Bag At The Store

Don’t buy by label alone. “Baby,” “petite,” and “creamer” tell you the size, not always the eating quality. A small yellow creamer and a small red creamer won’t roast the same way, even when the bags sit side by side.

When you’re standing in front of the shelf, check three things first. Look for firm potatoes with smooth skins. Skip bags with wet spots, deep eyes, wrinkling, or lots of green patches. According to Potatoes USA’s fresh potato guide, potato type affects starch level, texture, and the way each kind performs in the oven.

Size matters just as much as type. The best bag is the one where most potatoes are close in size. If half the bag is marble-small and the rest are golf-ball size, you’ll either pull some early or overcook some late.

You’ll also get better results from potatoes stored well before they reach your kitchen. The USDA SNAP-Ed potato page notes that potatoes can be waxy or starchy, which changes how they cook. It also points readers toward cool, dark storage, which helps keep texture steady before roasting day.

How To Roast Small Potatoes So They Crisp Up

Buying the right potato gets you halfway there. The rest comes down to prep. Most soggy trays happen for the same reasons: too much crowding, too little heat, or too much moisture left on the skin.

1. Heat the oven well. Start at 400°F or 425°F. A hot oven sets the crust fast.
2. Dry the potatoes after washing. Water is the enemy of browning.
3. Cut for even size. Halve creamers. Split fingerlings lengthwise. Leave marble-size potatoes whole.
4. Use enough oil to coat, not drown. You want shine, not a puddle.
5. Salt before roasting. Salt early so it sticks to the oil film.
6. Give them space. One crowded pan steams. Two roomy pans roast.
7. Turn once. Flip after the first side browns so you don’t knock off the crust too soon.

The Idaho Potato Commission’s roasted potato method uses a 400°F oven and shows how fast a simple roast comes together once the pan is set up right. That general approach works well for most small varieties, with only minor timing changes based on size.

Common Mistakes That Ruin The Tray

A few small slips can turn good potatoes into a flat, greasy side dish. These are the ones that show up most often:

• Using a dark, crowded pile: Potatoes need contact with hot metal and open space around them.
• Skipping the dry-off step: Damp skins steam before they brown.
• Adding sweet glazes too early: Honey, maple, or sugary sauces burn before the potato finishes.
• Seasoning with fresh garlic at the start: Garlic can scorch. Add it later or roast whole cloves beside the potatoes.
• Pulling them as soon as they’re soft: Tender isn’t enough. Wait for deep color on the cut sides.

One more thing: mixed-color bags can be great, but only when the sizes are close. If the yellow potatoes are big and the purple ones are tiny, roast them on separate trays or stagger when they go in. That small move saves the whole batch.

Which Small Potato Should You Buy

If you want the safest answer, buy baby yellow potatoes. They roast well under almost any seasoning plan and please the most people at the table. If you want firmer pieces, buy small reds. If you want more flavor and a little extra style, buy fingerlings. If you want bold color, add purple potatoes to the mix, but don’t rely on them as your only bag unless that earthy flavor is what you’re after.

For most kitchens, the smartest move is simple: buy the freshest small yellow or fingerling potatoes you can find, cut them evenly, dry them well, and roast them hot with enough space on the pan. Do that, and you’ll get the crisp edges and creamy centers people actually hope for when roasted potatoes hit the table.

Send us your feedbackTell us what you thought about this post

⚠Please use a real email you check. If it's fake or mistyped, your message won't reach us and we can't reply — wrong addresses are rejected automatically.

Name *Email *

Your comment *

Quick check — what is …? *

Send feedback